The seven worst news topics of 2016
main1 So many deaths:
The longest serving orchestral player
and so many, many more human tragedies.
2 Three avoidable orchestra strikes, unnecessary misery
3 New York Phil picks the wrong music director (as usual)
4 Airlines treat us like convicts
6 Crossover singers control the conversation
7 Brexit, Trump and the Vienna putsch.
So where’s the upside?
The upside is that this year will soon be over.
How interesting.
I wonder what percentage of the views on this site can be attributed to those seven?
There is plenty of upside with great musicians or institutions that don’t necessarily generate headlines, like Marlboro Music or Menahem Pressler.
Moreover, reports of the death of the record industry are always exaggerated. Every year leaves us at least a few great recordings. Kiril Gerstein’s recording of Liszt’s Transcendental Etudes comes to my mind. Even Norman Lebrecht gave five stars to some new recordings.
Add Danil Trifonov’s Liszt.
You forgot to mention Keith Emerson and Greg Lake, two giants in their own right.
…and Karel Husa (I see someone mentioned him below). I worked with him briefly at the Eastman School, playing his trio for violin, clarinet and piano with two fellow students. Lovely man!
“Crossover singers control the conversation” ONLY because they are given unmerited airtime and publicity. If people like Mr. Lebrecht and others in the media simply chose to ignore them the problem would be solved. At least Mr. Lebrecht sought balance with this story:
https://slippedisc.com/2016/12/who-would-you-cast-for-carousel-k-jenkins-or-cheryl-studer/
You forgot Joseph Silverstein!!!!!
Let me “second” that: perhaps the greatest musician, nicest and smartest and most genuine person to ever play in the Boston Symphony. And, without stretching the point a whole, you could include the entire USA. Unconscionable to have forgotten Joseph Silverstein among 2016’s “departed”, especially as he was still contributing so much to the world!
Great man and musician! Met him in several occasions and played for him at a master class once. But he died in 2015.
You’re absolutely right, Ricardo: it doesn’t seem like that long ago, but it is. As the kids say, “may bad”–and apologies to NL.
Belonging to the short list of top 20th century concertmasters both as superb fiddlers and excellent leaders including: Piastro, Dicterow and Mischakoff, but whose influence on the profession far exceeded theirs.
The upside is that nr 3 is not really true.
Agreed!
The possibility of new performances of your music in Manhattan does not make him the correct choice, the demand for Dutch music on the island isn’t quite as pressing and urgent as you assume. Painfully stiff Conductor who was hated by the players in Dallas, I see a tenure as vital as Maazel….
I never assumed interest in Dutch music in NY, and I don’t write Dutch music anyway, so this comment is pointless. And then, JvZw is popular & respected by most of the orchestras he works with.
PS:
Some reflections upon the new MD of the NY Phil can be found here:
http://subterraneanreview.blogspot.nl/2016/01/ny-phils-predicament.html
Unless of course it is. By around 2025, if not sooner, we shall probably know for sure.
Karel Husa, a giant figure in the land of his birth (Czechoslovakia–yes, that’s what it was then) and his adopted country. It is said that Music for Prague, 1968 is among the most widely performed works of the mid to late 20th century (and into the 21st). Of course, this is little known, as it is a piece for wind band.
I wonder if Prince is really just an et cetera in music deaths this year…
Bowie and Prince most likely fakes, including their deaths. Page 3 of this paper:
http://mileswmathis.com/game.pdf
To the list of the dead should be added Ed Rosen, amateur singer and opera fan from NYC.
Please do not forgot Johan Botha.
Another sad topic of 2016 — cancellations; particularly by Jonas Kaufmann whose career as a great operatic singer unfortunately seems to be essentially over.
Isn’t that a bit too pessimistic? Vocal cords are like bicycle’s inner tubes, when patched-up, they will last again for a considerable time, especially with a young bicycle.
It may be, unless it isn’t. By around 2022, if not sooner, we shall probably know for sure.
But for the Bordeaux it promises to have been quite a good year.