Which opera? All is revealed

Which opera? All is revealed

Opera

norman lebrecht

November 14, 2023

No cheating, please. This show has just opened in a major German house.

No idea? Try this.

Still not?

all photos (c) Monika Ritterhaus, courtesy of the unnamed opera house.

Surely you can recognise the famed soprano?

Revealed: It’s the Hamburg State Opera new Dmitri Tcherniakov production of Salome, starring Asmik Grigorian.

Comments

  • Anthony Sayer says:

    In Germany? I’d never have guessed…

  • giampi says:

    Salomé in Hamburg

  • Micaelo Cassetti says:

    Rosenkavalier??

  • David Wakeham says:

    MITRIDATE, RE DI PONTO Staatsoper Berlin.

  • Yv says:

    Le Nozze di Figaro

  • Bob Goldsmith says:

    I see that the Hamburg State Opera website gives no information about who will be singing in their operas, or the conductor. Only about the stage director. Which says it all really!

    • Andreas B. says:

      try clicking on “further information” and “cast”:

      you’ll find the complete production team, conductor and singers with CVs as well as chorus and orchestra for each production.

  • Louy says:

    Salomé évidemment !

  • Ms.Melody says:

    Easy. Salome by R.Strauss

  • Katia says:

    The name of the show is in the name of the photos when you click on them… but I like this game! More of this please!

  • John Daszak says:

    Ooh! Wait!! I know this…
    Err…. Così fan Tutte!!!
    What do I win????

    • norman lebrecht says:

      Try again

      • John Daszak says:

        Err… no, seriously, I KNOW this… err.. wait.. err… ah! Yes! “La Juive” Halevy???

        • Jonas says:

          Whatever the opera, the bloke sitting down admiring the girls underwear looks ridiculous! You wouldn’t catch me doing that on stage.

          • John Daszak says:

            Entführung???

          • Anthony Sayer says:

            Only backstage, then?

          • Novagerio says:

            Jonas: Ever heard of the Dance of the Seven Veils? So, the Prinzessin von Judea (still a minor in today’s world = 16 years old) is doing a lap dance on her pervert-stepfather, in order to get what she wants, the head of the Prophet in a silver plate. So, we get Blasphemy, Depravation, Decadence and Necrophilia.
            It was a shocker back in 1905, and it still is almost 120 years later.
            Personally I find this production interesting, and the cast looks very promising.

          • Jonas says:

            I’m shocked! As I said, I’d never do anything like this on stage. And now I’m led to believe that the singer in the photo is in fact Mr John Daszak, presumably the same John Daszak who gave Così fan Tutte as his first answer earlier in this post! Is this so? Does he not recognize himself? I’m totally confused!

          • John Daszak says:

            OK…OK… Fair cop! It’s me, yes! I was in this production of Salome in Hamburg. As someone fairly experienced in 20th century music and 20th century productions, I don’t find this version in any way strange. Much less strange than Castellucci’s 2018 production in Salzburg, which I was also in. Much less outrageous than the 2022 production in Paris, which I was also in…

  • Diane Valerie says:

    Salome. What else?

  • Melisande says:

    It was the birthday party of Herodes 2023 on which his daughter Salome begged for the head of Jochanaan. A modern version of a libretto by Oscar Wilde. An insulting production.

    • Peter X says:

      Oh dear… so Salomé cannot be given in a contemporary production?
      This is really great acting and singing and a testimony to Wildes and Strauss’ power. It is wonderfully refreshing to see this “biblical” story revived in a comprehensible staging. Excellent!

    • John Daszak says:

      How is it insulting?

      • Melisande says:

        The concept of the original biblical subject is so much stronger than the nowadays nouveau riche setting concept. History helps to fire one’s own imagination. Of course I’ve seen/heard this production!

  • Zach Woolfe says:

    Must be Salome, surely.

  • Althea T-H says:

    Female singers need to stop co-operating with this sleaze.

  • Joel Kemelhor says:

    Hansel und Gretel ?

  • Seneca says:

    Decadent pseudo-intellectual Eurotrash. I thought this style would already be passé by now. #Steuergeldverschwendung

  • MusicBear88 says:

    Salomé has always been an opera that is supposed to be shocking, hence why it played once at the MET and was then banned for 27 years. If we’re talking about it, then the production has, on some level, done its job.

  • Jimbo says:

    Tame compared to the atrociously violent and sickening production I last saw in Paris. The poor singers…..

  • Novagerio says:

    It could be worse, it could be La Traviata…

  • David A. Boxwell says:

    Hansel and Gretel. (The Witch is in a formal black gown; Hansel and Gretel are playing a naughty game).

  • MOST READ TODAY: