Parsifal without the singers

Parsifal without the singers

Orchestras

norman lebrecht

November 11, 2022

This brand-new arrangement is definitely an improvement.

None of that hair-washing humiliation and hours of confession.

 

Comments

  • Barry Guerrero says:

    As a tuba player, it amazes me how much sound Lee Tsarmaklis can squeeze out of an Eb tuba. He’s one of my favorites. I too like this ‘Reader’s Digest’ version of “Parsifal”. However, there’s so much great music in it, that I don’t mind occasionally sitting through the whole thing. I just don’t spend too much time pondering what it’s supposed to be about. I just listen – especially if you get good singers.

  • Anonymous Bosch says:

    Can’t wait to hear The Swingle Singers’ complete symphonies of Bruckner.

  • Antony Beaumont says:

    The same “bleeding chunks” as Henry Wood served up on his Wagner Nights, starting in the 1890s. Nothing new here.

  • RW2013 says:

    There are some who only go for the foot-washing.

  • Miriam Fournet says:

    I haven’t had time to listen to this arrangement and recording but for me the all time topper is a 1997 recording of “Parsifal, an orchestral quest”. An arrangement made by Henk de Vlieger and recorded by the Netherlands Radio Philharmonic under the direction of Edo de Waart. Superb arrangement, interpretation and playing on the BMG label.

  • Novagerio says:

    Hair-washing humiliation? Where?

    • Clem says:

      “Während Gurnemanz feierlich das Wasser sprengt, zieht Kundry ein goldenes Fläschchen aus ihrem Busen und giesst seinen Inhalt auf Parsifals Füsse aus; jetzt trocknet sie diese mit ihren schnell aufgelösten Haaren.”
      (Richard Wagner, “Parsifal”, Act III)

  • Andreas B. says:

    ‘brand-new’?

    in 2019 it was performed by the BBC NOW:

    https://youtu.be/DAnYWB3QoOY

  • Ulisses Papa says:

    Anti-Christian bias by an eminent musical critic, which proves that even the most insightful scholar is not necessarily blessed by the lights of wisdom.

  • Alank says:

    Norman will be pleased or displeased to know that his book “Music History in History” (a German version ) was prominently displayed in Hotel lobby in Bayreuth when we visited there last month.

  • Emilee says:

    if one of the singers is going to be Simon O’Neill then I’ll gladly enjoy Parsifal without the singers, especially THAT one. I certainly cannot enjoy any single opera WITH him in it.

  • music lover says:

    Parsifal is one of the greatest maaster works ever,for those who have an attention span bigger than an insect….Nice suite here,but nothing more,and nothing new(there are also much better versions,it´s well played but the conducting is quite shapeless and bland).Toscanini,Leinsdorf,and Abbado did more or less the same compilation.

    • David K. Nelson says:

      In one of his better recordings, don’t forget Eugene Ormandy’s pre-stereo Columbia LP of Parsifal excerpts with a Philadelphia Orchestra in great form, circa mid-1950s. It’s enough to fill the entire LP.

  • William Avery says:

    The late Andre Kostelanetz never got around to Wagner.

  • Leporello says:

    I think I heard parts of it at a wedding
    I attended the other day !

  • MOST READ TODAY: