US mezzo retires on social media

US mezzo retires on social media

News

norman lebrecht

September 03, 2022

Elegant Facebook message from the international mezzo-soprano, Susanne Mentzer:

From somewhere over the Pacific Ocean.
Sad/happy tears. Going out in my own terms. I could not have had a more loving and talented group of people to be with for my final show. My first opera was Figaro and my last was as well.
I have no more contracts so decided at 65.5 years of age and after 42 years singing professionally, it was a good time. Amazingly there were two people who have been with me through most of it who just happened to be working on this show: Laurie Feldman and Dennis Giacque.
I did not expect speeches, gifts, tears from just about everyone. Thank you to the Ozawa Matsumoto Festival for the amazing 3 weeks and the wonderful send-off. My partner on stage- Patrick Carfizzi is a gem. We should have started our comedy act sooner! Bryan Wagorn sneakily got Craig Rutenberg- my friend and collaborator since 1981-on zoom, then Ben and April sent a video. Nothing makes a mom cry like their son saying, “I am so proud of you.” He had to endure me being away sometimes and I look back incredulous at how I did that but I had a super parenting partner Drew Landmesser and a slew of amazing care givers. Anne, Julie, Niecie, Elisa Billey Becker…and a few more.
Now a list of thanks:
To the amazing power of serendipity
For studying cello when I was in 6th grade then moving to a place with no orchestra which led me to singing
To Mrs. Reindollar at Thurmont Middle School for throwing me out of choir for singing out of key- (it was my friend Elizabeth Anderson! Only made me work harder.)
To chorus conductor Gail Slezak, the late Richard Tomlinson (French teacher and musician )who, at Catoctin High School, saw promise in me. Gail is still a part of my life.
To Catoctin Mountain Park where I was matched with my friend Denise to sing at various programs and for having me demonstrate folk crafts at the Folk Center. It helped me get over stage fright.
To Richard Gaddes who treated me seriously when as a 17 yr old I inquired at the Santa Fe Opera for voice lessons.
To that same company for hiring me as an usher while in high school.
Shirley Thompson and George Buckbee at the University of the Pacific who encouraged me to change from Music therapy major to performance and to transfer to Juilliard.
To the late Rose Bampton and Marguerite Meyerwitz at Juilliard and Bertha Melnick who taught me how to count.
To my late voice teacher Norma Newton who never let me stop trying or settle for less of myself. She gave me a healthy technique and her friendship. I think of her nearly every day.
The late Joel Bloch at CAMI, my first manager who talked SO many people into hiring me even without an audition.
The late Kevin Hassler and the very alive Ken Benson at CAMI, and Karen Ashley.
The IMG gang on both sides of the pond- Alison Pybus and Tom Graham and their assistants, et al.
The late Jay K. Hoffman who connected me with Sharon Isbin and more.
To ADA Artists
To my extraordinary pianist Craig Rutenberg who taught me more than I can even explain
To David Gockley and Carlisle Floyd who elevated me from working as a receptionist at the Houston Grand Opera to joining the opera studio as a last minute sub.
To David and John Demain for giving me so many wonderful roles, including Ponnelle’s Ariadne and Anna Bolena with Dame Joan Sutherland.
To Juta Gleue who was a director in Köln and saw something in me that made her recommend me to the legendary Jean Pierre Ponnelle.
To James Levine who “got” me and what I did for 27 years at the Met, after hiring me sight unseen to replace Maria Ewing at Ravinia as Komponist in 1987
To Dennis Giacque, Pam Bullock, and the many coaches who helped me learn my music, sometimes pounding it into my brain.
To all the staff, crew, wardrobe and makeup/wig artists who helped me create the characters I portrayed.
To the supers who literally would stand for hours in rehearsals.
To the stage managers and promoters who would save me quite often.
To the covers.
To the canine emotional support I had- Holger, Charlie and now Shawna
To some amazing conductors who had a great influence on me: Eschenbach, Muti, the fore-mentioned Levine, Haitink, Colin Davis, Marriner, there are others- just forgetting.
To the other great directors who helped along the way- John Copley, Elijah Moshinsky, Giorgio Strehler,
To the incredible opera orchestras and fantastic choral artists.
To the artists with whom I shared the stage. We are only as good as our colleagues.
(Especially Patrick Rafftery, Carol Vaness, the late Jerry Hadley, Dwayne Croft, Tom Allen, Sam Ramey, Stan Ohlsen, Renee Fleming, Dawn Upshaw, Richard Stillwell, Bryn Terfel, Sylvia McNair, Mechtilde Gessendorf, Shirley Verrett and Flicka)
To the audience and fans who made me feel so special- especially this past week in Japan.
To my students who for 22 years have kept me humble
Thank you to some of the men in my life who at times (alas not always) were incredibly supportive- Drew Landmesser, the late Ted Anderson
To REG HUSTON who found me again and helped me revive that 19 year-old self (before I was abused in my first marriage to the violent alcoholic), and who has patience and understanding; who will be with me until the real end.
Last, but not least, to my son Ben for bringing such joy and meaning to my life and to my extraordinary late parents who were unfailingly supportive. They were always there.
You can see how blessed I have been. 4 continents, 42 years. It seems a dream.
Apologies for leaving anyone out- too many years is a lot to remember! I

Comments

  • rentayenta says:

    what names and memories madam mentzer brings back. big hug to you and hat tip.

  • rentayenta says:

    Long ago and far away….another great devotee of Santa Fe Opera who will always be respected and loved.

    https://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/article/Philip-Eisenberg-S-F-Opera-prompter-dies-3177102.php

  • Del Boy says:

    I saw her in Figaro at the Met many years ago, and she radiated star quality – her voice superb and frankly the stongest member of that cast.

    A wonderful singer.

    Famous moment with The Big Fella:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jZHy1gYDb8Q

    @12-54

  • Maria says:

    Very gracious retirement letter and the best I’ve ever read. The professional singing world has changed out of all recognition and the pandemic finished off what had already started. So many singers filling music colleges, paying thousands, doing all these competitions but yet no real work out there for themand agents far more selective, unless you are willing to sing for peanuts or nothing in the hope of being noticed and becoming a star singer, and so few become stars. Sadly the middle level on which you could earn a living and afford to buy a modest flat or house and have ‘a life’, has all but disappeared. Wish her well as she had a wonderful career.

  • MMcGrath says:

    I remember many fine evenings with Susanne Mentzer. Thank you for those memories. What a grand moment of courage and savvy for the great James Levine to”elevate” her as she says.

  • Diane Estes says:

    God bless you for blessing us with your vocal talents and all for all your many years of wonderful memories.
    Brava!!!

  • Paul says:

    I vividly remember tuning into the radio broadcast of that 1987 Ravinia ARIANDE and being bowled over by the mezzo singing the Composer. Turned me into a fan on the spot. Thank you, ma’am, for all you’ve given us!

  • Una Barry says:

    http://www.bruceduffie.com/mentzer.html

    Nice interview between Susanne Mentzer and Bruce Duffie in Chicago that I transcribed for him in 2017. They were recorded in Chicago on January 5,1987, and January 30, 1999, some of which was published in the Massenet Newsletter in January, 1988.

    Worth a read!

  • oberon says:

    Bravissima Susanne! Especially loved her as the Composer (ARIADNE AUF NAXOS) and as Melisande…

  • Heidi V says:

    What a wonderful tribute and grateful to have coached with you once at your home in Chicago. You have inspired me alone my musical journey. Thank you!

  • Tiredofitall says:

    A person as lovely as her singing. To boot, Susanne is down to earth…I wonder if I ever saw her off-stage not sporting a baseball cap.

    A career well done! I hope you will continue with your writing.

  • Zvi says:

    Unfortunately I saw her only on TV. Her Nicklaus was incomparable.

  • Harriet Lindblom says:

    Saw her as Cio Cio San in Butterfly at Met many years ago, and remember that her real son played the little boy (before puppets!). And as he negotiated stairs, fell down them, picked himself up like a trooper and not a beat of music was missed! We’ll miss you Ms. Mentzer! Enjoy your retirement!

  • Dairy Maid says:

    I first heard Suzanne when she was in the HGO program—l forget the name of it now. But l remember that her talent was matched by her graciousness. This lovely letter proves she never lost either.

  • GeorgeRipley says:

    Social media platforms have become powerful sources of information, shaping our awareness of the financial world and the potential of ico crypto Through these platforms, we gain insights into emerging trends, market analysis, and expert opinions. The dynamic nature of social media keeps us updated on the latest developments, helping us make informed decisions in the ever-changing landscape of finance. It’s essential to leverage these platforms to expand our understanding of ICO Crypto, unlocking opportunities and staying ahead in this transformative industry. By utilizing social media wisely, we can tap into a wealth of knowledge and make the most of the financial world’s potential.

  • MOST READ TODAY: