Lesbians in a palazzo light up the Venice Music Biennale

Lesbians in a palazzo light up the Venice Music Biennale


norman lebrecht

September 25, 2022

Review by Shirley Apthorp, exclusive to Slipped Disc:

NOTWEHR – Scuola Grande di San Rocco – Venice Music Biennale

A lesbian affair in a prison cell in the middle of a Venetian Palazzo – only Annelies van Parys and her librettist Gaea Schoeters could pull this off.

‘Notwehr’ tells an unlikely love story between two very different women, both unjustly imprisoned. The Activist, who is standing up for her ideals, initially clashes with the Common Woman, imprisoned for murdering and castrating her husband (we will later learn why). As the two women learn each other’s stories, their enforced proximity blossoms into something deeper.

Notwehr is staged in the grand hall of the Scuola Grande di San Rocco, amidst vast and lavish Tintoretto paintings, a setting that is breathtaking in itself. Van Parys (pictured) takes the madrigals of early 17th century composer Adriano Banchieri as the starting-point for a score that is deft and telling. She brings many years of experience in music theatre to the task, and it shows – idiomatic instrumental writing, strong vocal lines, and her characteristic ability to weave in and out of music history without losing her own voice all contribute to the evening’s strength.

A good libretto – all too rare in contemporary opera – certainly helps. Schroeters strikes just the right balance between poetry and prose, never too wordy, but always a compelling narrative. The two women’s stories unfold without pathos, all the more moving for their economy.

There are some teething problems. The first madrigal falls apart completely, perhaps because the vocal ensemble Venetiaeterna and the instrumentalists of the ERMESensemble are placed in different parts of the hall; but things soon pull back together, and the shifts between Banchieri’s bold madrigals and van Parys’ articulate, taut score grow in assurance as the evening progresses. Johanna Zimmer and Els Mondelaers, as the two imprisoned women, inhabit their roles completely. Sjaron Minailo’s “Mise en Scene” places a spare yet versatile metal cage in the centre of the hall, and costumes the women in garb that echoes the Tintoretto paintings, reminding us that women throughout history have been punished for acts of self-defence.

Notwehr is a co-production between the Venice Biennale, the Studio Minailo, the HERMESensemble, and the Belgian Muziektheater Transparent; it is clearly born to travel, and will surely move on to other spaces to grow and flourish.

How about a performance run in Iran?



  • Lothario Hunter says:

    Trying to run a lesbian story in Iran? Nitimur in vetitum.

    I am so very sorry to be dashing everyone’s hopes, but regrettably a performance run in Iran will not be possible. Only the Supreme Muti was allowed to perform in Iran with his little Angels (i.e., Cherubinis) in 2017. Muti’s soprano was not allowed to sing alone at the time, for decency reasons, a prohibition that Muti promptly accepted, so I am afraid a lesbian affair is out of the question.

    Muti went on and on bragging of the honor of performing in Iran, sanctioned but the equally Supreme Iranian leader, in the same way he bragged about receiving Putin’s Order of Friendship. Watchers agree that the Maestro has a penchant for being recognized by such personalities, and we applaud him sincerely because he deserves such appreciation. As Muti boasted in interviews, only Karajan was allowed to play western classical music in Iran, but before the revolution. Again with such high benchmarks to meet, this lesbians-in-a-prison cell story, though laudable, is a no-no.

    (A preventive disclaimer to avoid rushed attacks of hard core fans: let’s be very clear, unlike in the Russian love story, here we do not imply a bromance, and even less a convergence of ideologies between Muti and the Iranian theocracy. As we well know in Chicago, Muti is a massive supporter of “hair” in general, and of women exposing .. “hair” in particular, whether metoo allows that or not!)

    Since we are in a Latin mood today, I suggest we all continue to imitate Muti, and start practicing on this website: https://www.mondly.com/blog/2021/07/29/cool-latin-phrases/

  • Hugo Preuß says:

    Why does it have a German title? Belgian composer and writer, produced in Venice. Perhaps I am missing something, but the title has me confused.

  • Peter X says:

    Notwehr isn’t an exploitation film by Russ Meyer.