Maestro would have been 75 this week
NewsGiuseppe Sinopoli, born Venice 2 November 1946, died Berlin 21 April 2001.
Fascinating man, unusual conductor, died in action.
Comments
MOST READ TODAY:
-
Orchestras
Powerhouse violinist quits in Cleveland
We hear that Stephen Rose, former head of…
-
RIP
Concertmaster dies, 44
The Finnish music world is in mourning for…
-
Opera
Opera singers ‘face a mental health crisis’
Singers’ agents tell us of a tsunami of…
-
Opera
German opera chief quits at Christmas
The city of Würzburg has been shaken by…
Sinopoli’s Schubert 8 with the Philharmonia is DEFINITIVE, the single greatest performance of this masterwork imaginable. (Not to be confused with his later performance with the Staatskapelle Dresden, an ordinary and unmemorable reading.) The Philharmonia Schubert 8 leaves me emotionally devastated every single time I listen to it. If that’s all Sinopoli achieved in his career, then it was a great career. But his career was more than that.
French magazine “Diapason” ranked Sinopoli/Philharmonia “Unfinished” in their top 4 – out of eighty renditions -, along with Davis/Boston (Philips), Cluytns/Berlin (Warner) and Böhm/Vienna (DG).
His Schumann 2nd
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=08tuOZvQIzI
and Manfred Overture
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CfFtovx2hsg
are second to none and I don’t think will ever be bettered, as inflated as that may sound. Likewise his Strauss Salome with Studer.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z7anMdrlbow
The Dresden Schumann 2nd is nearly as fascinating. Strangely enough, 3rd and 4th are rather weak.
It is the Schumann 2nd with the VPO, linked above, that is the one to beat.
He was one of the greats. His recording of Bruckner 7 is in my top 3.
At his best a terrific musician with an exceptional ear for texture and never less than interesting. As an aside, the earlier article talks about Van Beinum dying in a “serene” rehearsal of Brahms 1. I’ve heard two of his three recordings of Brahms 1 and there’s nothing “serene” about the interpretation…
His Dresden Bruckner 5 recording is another great one.
Feted in the rest of Europe and Japan, he was despised by quite a number of music critics in the UK who leapt at every opportunity to make fun of his start-stop tendencies, his mirror-image conducting and deconstructionist habits. His interpretations were never bland but his reception by the British musical establishment is yet another example of the sneering arrogance it so frequently exhibits, completely oblivious to the opinions and praise accorded to artists elsewhere. Even the Philharmonia airbrushes him out of the list of its principal conductors. But as so very often happens, reputations ditched and dashed in one part of the world have a habit of recovering over time.
I don’t know about the rest of Europe, but the french critics had nothing but contempt for him.
Wasn’t he persona non grata at either the BPO or VPO because he supposedly lost his place during a performance of a Schumann symphony? Maddeningly uneven in Mahler; imo superb 5th and dreadful 2nd.
His Mahler 2nd, Edinburgh Festival, shook me to the core.
I’ve always found Sinopoli’s recording of Brahms’ Ein deutsches Requiem very moving – he captures the sense of mystery from the very start.
In a period of about two years in my life, a long time ago, I played the Verdi Requiem first with Muti, then with Inbal, and finally with Sinopoli. What you wrote — captures the sense of mystery from the start — precisely expresses how I felt playing Sinopoli’s interpretation.
His recording of Ariadne auf Naxos, with a truly outstanding cast, is wonderful.
While it’s far from the best sung version, Sinopoli’s Dresden recording of “Das Lied von der Erde” is superbly played and conducted. I listen to it just for the incredibly fine playing of the Staatskapelle (those woodwinds!).
Giuseppe Sinopoli was an indifferent conductor, conducting a few good works and many bad ones. I doubt that anyone would call him great. Since he died many years ago and has been eclipsed, why the tribute?
A valid opinion, albeit stated in a seemingly intentionally mean-spirited and nasty way. Sinopoli’s versions of Ariadne and Nabucco are my go-to recordings.