What happens when you stage a rare opera? Nobody comes to review

What happens when you stage a rare opera? Nobody comes to review


norman lebrecht

September 28, 2017

The Barber Inistitute at Birmingham University is presently putting on the first performances of Nicola Porpora’s Agrippina since its premiere in 1708.

You’d have thought that might have attracted a bit of attention. Nothing of the sort. Locals are seething that the opera has been ignored by national critics. One of them, PhD student Sara Clethero, has sent us her review.

Although we are not a review site, we make an exception for this opera – otherwise it might go unnoticed for the next 309 years.

A race against time

L’Agrippina: Porpora

review by Sara Clethero

I fought my way through the cycle race traffic on my way to the Barber Institute at Birmingham University to see Porpora’s Agrippina and I was so glad I did. The singing was superb, the orchestral playing joyfully precise, and the production an inspiration to see.

 ‘Popora’s cheerful unconcern with decorum’ in the words of Prof. Andrew Kirkman, the musical director, is given full rein, making for a refreshingly pantomimic acting style in some cases and a very direct delivery of the recitative text (translated into English)  – necessary, since the performance lasted some four hours. The most undecorous performances were the duets between bass baritone Marc Labonnette, as the servant Planco, an extraordinary voice which could go anywhere (does he sing Wagner?) and Charlotte Beament singing his ambivalent female collaborator.

Kirkman calls this opera by Handel’s heavyweight rival ‘a wasp’s nest of intrigue and incest’. He conducted with finesse and precision, setting the singers and instrumentalists free to do their formidable best. A multimedia stage design created a magical setting for the piece in the iconic, but technically limited, Barber Concert Hall.

 Work of this freshness and immediacy gives me hope that we might be finally moving into a new era of opera performance, where the audience members are joyful fellow-travellers with committed performers rather than respectfully mute witnesses of a specialised, and ultimately irrelevant, art form.




  • Olassus says:

    That’s where Janet Baker first got noticed, working with Anthony Lewis in the early 60s. She was singing something we now take for granted, but I can’t remember what.

    Muti conducted a fabulous Porpora cantata three years ago.

  • John Borstlap says:

    Great that such forgotten works are being revived. Porpora was a teacher of Joseph Haydn, famous but died poor.

  • Steven says:

    Very glad to have discovered Porpora through this post. Thank you Ms Clethero!

  • Zelda Macnamara says:

    I love what I have been able to find of Porpora on youtube. I would really have liked to go to this opera but it clashed with a long-planned visit to the WNO in Cardiff, and other commitments. Hope this might be the beginning of a Porpora revival.

  • James says:

    I do sometimes wonder when Canteloubes’ Vercingètorix will see the light of day again.

    I do not know why it has been nearly totally forgotten- the first person to play the leading role (the person it was written for and the person with whom the composer collaborated- there is video footage), was the great Georges Thill- he sang it in the prime of his career.

  • Sara Clethero says:

    Thanks, everyone!
    Those who did all the work to get this piece off the ground are really grateful for the support!
    Sara Clethero