Vintage shot: Telling a conductor what he’s worth

Vintage shot: Telling a conductor what he’s worth

Orchestras

norman lebrecht

December 24, 2024

This is the forbidding Erich Leinsdorf, conducting the LA Phil in the 1980s.

When he wasn’t looking, someone put the sign up and oboist David Weiss snapped this shot.

Leinsdorf was not renowned for having a sense of humour.

Comments

  • zandonai says:

    a humorous photograph of a conductor with photographic memory.

  • William Keller says:

    His casual and rushed conducting of a 1977 Met Walküre I saw was strange. It was as if he did not want to be there.

  • drummerman says:

    When he was music director in Boston, he doted over the musicians like a mother hen. On his first visit with them to Carnegie Hall, he warned them about all of the supposed “dangers” of New York City, ie. crossing the streets, pickpockets, etc. and he told them: “Whatever you do, don’t eat any fried foods.” Whereupon they all ordered fried chicken, fried fish, etc. From that day on, a meal of fried food was referred to as a “Leinsdorf dinner.”

  • msc says:

    Chortled audibly! Thanks.

  • Max Raimi says:

    He actually did have a sense of humor of sorts. He would memorize a joke and subject us to it in rehearsal. He never displayed any ability to react to a real time event in an amusing or amused manner, however. Granted, I only saw him at the end of his career. But I always found him to be a bully and a pedant, his performances utterly stupefying. On the evidence of earlier recordings, it wasn’t always so.

  • Pagano says:

    When on the only occasion that I occupied the star dressing room at Avery Fisher, he came into the room smoking a huge cigar. I said, good evening Maestro, my what a small cigar. Without smiling, he said “so young and so sarcastic” and exited.

  • JamesM says:

    He once gave a telling interview to Ulla Colgrass about the importance of a music director living in the community of his orchestra, and why it is an impossibility in our time.
    Recording? I think his best is Korngold: Die tote Stadt.

  • Stephen Balderston says:

    If memory serves me correctly, we had the occasion to play the concert version of Strauss’ Rosenkavalier with Erich Leinsdorf when I was a youngster in the St. Louis Symphony in the early 1980s. At the end of our first reading rehearsal, I remember him saying to us “next time, remind me to bring a piece that you know”…
    However…his interpretation of La Valse is forever etched into my memory as one of my favorite orchestral performances of my career. It was sheer magic.

  • Ralph Sauer says:

    As a member of the Los Angeles Philharmonic during that time, I also remember giving him a T-shirt with a picture of a palm tree that said, “Non-Ritardando Club.” He wore it proudly. Never was he a “bully and a pendant” with the LA Phil.

  • Adam Stern says:

    He seems to me to have been a musician who was either “on” or “off”. I’m glad that I experienced him on some of his “on” days. In a lifetime of hearing many performances of Prokofiev’s “Romeo and Juliet”, Leinsdorf’s performance of a lengthy suite from it still stands as the best I ever heard. The tension the orchestra and he built in “The Death of Tybalt” was actually frightening.

  • M2N2K says:

    He did have his own kind of sense of humor. When he was not satisfied with musicians’ preparedness, at the end of the rehearsal he liked to say: “Now go home and OVERLOOK your [private] parts!”. Another of his favorite phrases was: “Playing without precision is like giving someone your APPROXIMATE telephone number!”.

  • caranome says:

    In a NYT profile on his 50th anniversary as conductor, he said this was his fondest memory: in rehearsal at the old Met of Moses n Aaron, the plan was to do the Exodus scene of Jews leaving the desert, send the chorus home, then orchestra continue. So the scene ended, n Leinsdorf said “the Jews can go home now,” n half the orchestra got up n walked off stage. He ended rehearsal right there n had a good laugh.

  • MOST READ TODAY: