Grigolo and Pumeza will sing for Putin masses

Grigolo and Pumeza will sing for Putin masses

Opera

norman lebrecht

May 21, 2024

The Kremlin newspaper Rossiyskaya Gazeta is bragging that ‘the best opera singers in the world – from Italy, Brazil, South Africa, Israel, Armenia and Russia – will be heard in the heart of St. Petersburg’ on May 31.

Those taking part in the state event include the Italian tenor Vittorio Grigolo, Armenian soprano Juliana Grigoryan, Pumeza Matshikiza from South Africa, the bass Mateus Franz (Switzerland) and the Israeli mezzo-soprano Maya Gour, who is a soloist at Cologne Opera.

Grigolo was banned at Covent Garden and other western companies after claims of misconduct.

Comments

  • Operacentric says:

    Looks more like Netrebko to me.

  • william osborne says:

    Hmmm. Note the absence of Anna Netrebko.

    I also think of the opponents of the Kremlin who have been murdered: Aleksei Navalny, Yevgeny Prigozhin, Sergei Yushenkov, Anna Politkovskaya, Aleksandr Litvinenko, Natalya Estemirova, Sergei Magnitsky, Alexander Litvinenko, and Boris Nemtsov, among others. There’s also the pro-Western Ukrainian leader Viktor Yushchenko who was poisoned but survived though with his face grotesquely deformed by dioxin. I wonder if Russians understand why Eastern Europeans and Germans so abhor the idea of being drawn into the Russian sphere, despots like Viktor Orbán and Aleksandr Lukashenko aside.

    • Nicholas says:

      Why would Russians want the Germans drawn into their sphere when the German parliament has just decriminalized the possession of child pornography? I’m sure that would make German pedophiles happy. It seems to me Germany is becoming creepier and sicker. Slouching towards Weimar Germany I guess.

      • william osborne says:

        An incomprehensible law change in my view, but it no way justifies the Kremlin’s history of murdering political dissidents. Until Russia changes these habits, it will remain isolated from Europe, and sadly, in some respects, not even seen as a European country–or least not one living by modern European standards.

        It is also a great misfortune that there was a 15 to 20 year period after the fall of the wall when the West could have began integrating Russia into the EU and helping it build sensible political and economic structures that would have avoided the horrible mess Europe is in now. We could have all been living in friendship, cooperation, prosperity, and peace. Sadly, some of the worst people in both the USA and Russia led us in the wrong direction.

      • william osborne says:

        I checked on this new law in Germany. The maximum sentences remain in place. German prosecutors and police found the old law too inflexible. For example, teachers sometimes found images that could be used for child porn on students’ phones and forwarded them to the child’s parents so they could deal with it. Under the old law, they would have been prosecuted for “distributing” child pornography. The new law allows for such exemptions, or for things like parents’ groups inadvertently downloading images that might be defined as child pornography when they’re just sending photos of the family at the beach or something. So no real change in Germany’s prosecution of child abuse, just better, more effective laws.

        https://apnews.com/article/germany-child-sexual-abuse-19e743b19057aa7345bf3cba4a8f6fff

        • Jim C. says:

          Right. But I’ve learned the hard way in life that you can’t argue with the righteous. They’ll just start to go after you in retaliation.

      • Jim C. says:

        They didn’t decriminalize child porn. They reduced the minimum sentence because some people were being unfairly drawn into the investigations and it was the *prosecutors* who wanted more leeway. Child porn is not legal in Germany.

  • Anthony Sayer says:

    I’m no fan of Grigolo, but ‘claims’ of misconduct should not be sufficient to destroy a career. That’s what courts of law are for.

    • william osborne says:

      It’s also within the rights of employers to act on these claims. If the alleged perpetrator disagrees with their decision, they can go to court. Few do for the simple reason that the allegations are usually true.

  • IP says:

    I tried to listen to Grigolo’s latest album but I had to resign after 1 minute 32 seconds. If there are more like him, let Mr P have the whole batch at a discount

  • Sam McElroy says:

    I just don’t understand how anyone with frontal lobes intact can go and create art in Putin’s Russia, or in his buddy Maduro’s Venezuela. You need to be a committed moral consequentialist – or just ignorant – to do either.

    • NC says:

      Perhaps you can enlighten us about when Ukraine invaded Russia and tortured, raped and killed its citizens.

      False equivalency is a dangerous thing!

      • Sam McElroy says:

        I don’t understand your question. Ukraine never invaded Russia. Nor do I make that claim. The opposite is true, which is why I do not understand anyone with decent values going there to perform, if invited by the Russian state. Where is my false equivalency?

    • Ivan Grozny says:

      If you believe that misguided Western foreign policy has contributed to the conflict in Ukraine it may not be that difficult.

      • Sam McElroy says:

        Such a belief is utter nonsense. NATO is a defensive alliance, not an offensive one. Members apply to join, not because they wish to invade their neighbors, but because they seek a defensive shield against invasion from mad men like Putin. It is utterly false to claim a defensive shield as an existential threat. This is Russia’s grand excuse.

        • Ivan Grozny says:

          Such a belief is quite common in the West. This isn’t the forum to debate whether it us justified or not.

  • Charles Macmillan says:

    On the basis of where public opinion is now, is performing in Russia any worse than performing in Israel?

  • Jcr says:

    Or they could just be singing to a Russian audience… Can we please keep politics out of classical music? This is getting tiresome… Imagine if American orchestras stopped playing Beethoven during World War III… You know why they didn’t? Because people weren’t so fragile and offended over everything.

  • Helpsalot says:

    Reminds me of that song; Massa’s in de cold, cold, ground.

  • Marinella says:

    Expected anything from a circus guy like Grigolo, but certainly not from Pumeza. Some people don’t have any kind of morals… Shameful. And sad

  • Barney says:

    Mateus Franz? There is no record of any singer with that name.

  • Barney says:

    Who is Mateus Franz? There’s no record of a singer of that name anywhere on the internet.

    AI?

    • Meal says:

      This seems to me to be an incorrect retranslation from the Cyrillic transliteration. On the website linked his name is written Матеуса Франца which should read most probably Matheus França. However, the event in St. Petersburg is not listed under his name in OperaBase or on his personal website.

  • Barney says:

    I’ve found him now. He seems to be a company member in Bern.

  • Scott says:

    This concert should be billed as the has-been’s of the opera world, starring Grigolo and Netrebko.

  • gertrude says:

    put <Netrebko and Grigolo in Any Operahouse and the booking sites will crash within no time as it happened in Vienna

  • MOST READ TODAY: