Dear Alma: Meet Slippedisc’s new agony aunt

Dear Alma: Meet Slippedisc’s new agony aunt

Daily Comfort Zone

norman lebrecht

August 03, 2023

All human life passes through these portals, some of it raw and confused.

As a service to readers, we have appointed an agony aunt with international experience of both orchestral and chamber music. Her column will run on Fridays. You can post your questions to her in the comments below.

Here is a taster of things to come:

Dear Alma,

The Maestro keeps asking to see me in his room after rehearsal. He usually takes (and needs) a shower. How many ways do I have to say no?

Avoiding the Shower

Dear Avoiding,

First things first. You’ve got this. Take a deep breath, and let’s look at the options. It was only a short while ago that you would be in a sticky situation with no options, but now, with a little planning, you will be in the driver’s seat.

1 Protect yourself. Get any kind of evidence you can – have your phone on record at the end of rehearsal until you get him/her on tape. Tell a friend, confidentially, and have them write down the details and date. Write down anything you remember from previous encounters.

2 Look ahead 5 years and decide what you want your life to look like. Do you want this to be an anonymous blip, or is this your call to action? If the latter, be prepared for being outed, with colleagues strongly agreeing/disagreeing with you, and future work opportunities negatively affected. The word will get out and this will be a permanent part of your unofficial resume. But it also may open up a new chapter for you, and you will certainly be a hero to many other people in similar situations.

3 Consider talking to a lawyer before taking the next step.

4 Make an appointment with the highest person of your management, at a time when colleagues won’t see you going to the offices. If you wish to remain anonymous, have a confidentiality contract with you to be signed before you talk. Explain that you are there to help them protect themselves from a harmful situation – everyone knows that this is most likely not the first time that this sweaty arm-waver has made untoward advances – imagine if you had been some naive member and things had gotten out of control? You are here to protect the organization, and would like them to take care of this immediately and without using your name.

5 Lastly – if you want to take care of this alone, here are some more ways of “hosing down” this ridiculous, stinky dinosaur who can’t even smell the “Me Too” coffee thats been percolating in the kitchen for several years.
– “I would love to come see you – give me a minute because I just have to apply my anti-fungal cream – I am having a major flare-up!”
– “Maybe tomorrow? My boyfriend/girlfriend has a body-building competition that I have to go to today”
– “For sure! I was hoping to ask you anyway – can you be a guest on my podcast “Behind Closed Doors – the Secret Lives of the Extremely Successful”?
– “Totally! I was wanting to introduce you to my partner anyway, a lawyer for workplace discrimination! I can bring they/them along!”

But seriously, you are a powerful, successful musician and you don’t have to take any BS from anyone. The world is big and beautiful, and no one can stop you from driving your own destiny.

Comments

  • Brian says:

    Dear Avoiding the Shower,

    I asked my friends – a soprano, a mezzo-soprano, a violinist and a pianist – and they all recommended going to that meeting. Good luck!
    Love,
    Alma

    • Mecky Messer says:

      This site acts as the Feuilleton pages for the “insiders” of the industry, giving coverage every time a conductor marries the concertmaster, or the flutist, or the student, or the student’s student….

      Oh, but I forget: those cases are “real love”. Yeah, the aspiring musician who 5 minutes ago was sharing a crowded apartment with 5 other people and sharing 1 bathroom in london marries someone 30 years older and 200 pounds heavier because….its real love

      Surely they didn’t get into any showers…..

  • Mecky Messer says:

    The alt right defending the maestro and not getting censored for comments (unlike this one)

    In 3…2…1…..

    • Bone says:

      The maestro is gross, as is any young person who shacks up with him/her as a means of advancing their career (and possibly making #MeToo allegations later).
      That’s just my opinion, though: regardless of political affiliation, adults should be able to do just about whatever they want with another adult.

    • Bass Player says:

      What does this have to do with the “alt-right”? Sexual predators run the political gamut from Donald Trump to Harvey Weinstein.

  • Fortunately it wasn't Alma R. says:

    For those like me who did not know, agony aunt is British for advice columnist. I’m told Alma eventually had an affair with Walter G.

  • Nannerl says:

    Dear Alma,
    Very concise, clear steps, useful information for a variety of situations! Looking forward to Friday.

  • Wannaplayguitar says:

    Hmm…..the ad that just popped up under this article reads ‘Full Body oil massage’……Dear Aunty Alma I am being intellectually harassed by the hot oil body massage industry whilst trying to read erudite articles about the comings and goings of the classical music world…..do the two subjects share the same algorithm by any chance? I think we should be told

    • Kyle says:

      It is a source of perpetually astonishment to me – along with some amusement – that people constantly out themselves by not understanding how internet advertising works.

  • MMcGrath says:

    Am I missing something? Is this intended as comedic and ironic?

    Or is this “serious” advice to someone who apparently has trouble navigating everyday life?

  • Zarathusa says:

    Congrats Alma and “Good Luck”…you’ll need it!!! BTW…I agree that Ava Dodd deserves the Prix Ives Prize…and I would have voted for her even if she were tone-deaf and speechless! Auntie A, is that O.K. by you???

  • Lola Mouse says:

    Dear Alma,

    I have a problem! The concertmaster of an orchestra I’m auditioning for used to be my teacher and doesn’t like me very much! How can I prepare for the audition for which they probably have a say in who gets in or not?

    Sincerely,

    Lola Mouse

  • Sue Sonata Form says:

    No, I preferred the funny answers!! Humour is the best ardour-destroyer!! Let’s see if we can offer some fresh alternatives:

    “Sorry, I’ve got a pressing engagement; a couple of shirts to iron”.

  • Confused Goldfish says:

    Dear Alma,

    I have so much repertoire for college auditions and so little time to practice it all! How can I effectively organize my practicing and do you have tips for memorizing multiple concertos and solo bach partitas? I have the memory of a goldfish!

  • MOST READ TODAY: