Chicago Symphony has new composer in residence
mainJessie Montgomery has been chosen by Riccardo Muti as the orchestra’s next house composer.
She succeeds Missy Mazzoli.
Comments
MOST READ TODAY:
-
Orchestras
Powerhouse violinist quits in Cleveland
We hear that Stephen Rose, former head of…
-
News
Panic buttons at Cleveland
The steady departure of cherished professors at the…
-
RIP
Concertmaster dies, 44
The Finnish music world is in mourning for…
-
Opera
Opera singers ‘face a mental health crisis’
Singers’ agents tell us of a tsunami of…
checks all the boxes
I hope you mean that she’s a wonderful young composer and that this is a great opportunity for her and the CSO.
I agree — the few pieces from her that I’ve heard all show that she is a composer very much worth listening to, full stop.
That is good to read – I haven’t heard any of her work (yet) but will try to hunt out some performances online – Muti usually has sound judgement, so I find this an interesting opportunity
But there’s nothing in her music that invites criticism. Listen to her Strum (scroll down a bit):
https://floridaorchestra.org/for-composer-jessie-montgomery-music-is-her-voice/
Or her 1 violin rhapsody:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3JLb_nAnLC8
Also, in her teaching music, she has cancelled the mistake, which is quite an achievement:
http://listeningtoladies.com/episode5
So, finally, everything that’s done by anyone is perfect.
She also improvises on a Haydn string quartet:
http://palmbeachartspaper.com/composer-montgomery-seeks-the-intersection-of-styles/
Unfortunateluy it is not possible to have Haydn improvising on a Montgomery piece. But of course, the ‘intersection of styles’ is where the real interest of music begins.
Etc. etc…
But it is a very positive sign of the times that women composers get the chance to be heard, in spite of all the PC nonsene wrapped around it. Maybe somewhere in the future some really great music will emerge from the maelstrom.
…surely, sir…..”male” strum….?
You mean woke-washing?
Why so defensive?
Is she gay? That’s a pretty big checkbox.
In other words, non-white + non-male = non-qualified.
I recall an interview in which Muti despaired at commissioning new music.
He noted that although he had conducted “world premieres” every year for years, none of it had ever gained traction in the music world.
It would be interesting to know how or if that track record is shaping his choices.
She is a fine composer.
Montgomery is clearly very talented and a fast rising star. Good for the CSO. I am sure that many complained with Missy Mazzoli and Anna Clyne were selected as resident composers. It is surprising considering how active she is that she isn’t teaching anywhere. Some smart conservatory should add her to their faculty.
I thought I had read somewhere that she was teaching at Mannes but the press release and her bio don’t seem to indicated that.
How can you teach when you have cancelled the concept of mistake?
@NL:
That voting mechanism (which I still don’t like, because it is far too easily fooled and thus open to exploitation. Which we have seen here already.) is way slower than before your design update. It also seems to mix things up. I had a thumb down vote on several of my posts, apparently by me. I have no problem criticizing myself in general. But these were some pretty awesome posts of mine that I never would have downvoted. 😉 Also, some posts (not mine) have negative votes, which shouldn’t even be possible (but I agree with the sentiment.)
Anyone else seeing this?
“Also, some posts (not mine) have negative votes, which shouldn’t even be possible (but I agree with the sentiment.)”
For example:
https://i.imgur.com/SSkySlH.png
@NL:
Clicking on “Booo!” on Sarah’s post also adds boos to TOPO. Reloading the page removes all my excessive boos and the first boo from Sarah and gives a boo to TOPO instead. Which I didn’t boo. In other words:
THE ELECTION IS RIGGED!!!11!
For once, it seems to be true.
I guess we know now how I ended up with me downvoting myself.
Did I mention that I think this should not happen?
@NL:
And I liked it that linked images were opened on this site and could be closed when done admiring them. Now clicking on an image link will open that link thus leaving SD. Maybe I’m the only one, but I would like to see this feature again in the future.
Despite my criticism all the time, I prefer the new design, now that most of the kinks are ironed out.
I forgot the link:
https://i.imgur.com/pWnrTqc.png
Does her violin Rhapsody sound like Arvo Pärt to anyone else? up-yes, down-no
The thing about Muti is that he doesn’t really care about contemporary music. If he did, he would judiciously revive some of the works that he conducted throughout his career. Can someone seriously think that in seven decades of making music there were no pieces better than, say Martucci’s concerto for piano, a work that he championed? (And don’t get me wrong, I am glad he does champion Martucci, even though he’s not exactly a great composer.)
But hey, contemporary music is part of the job description and must be done.
I think that is about right. Muti goes through the motions but doesn’t seem to really champion any contemporary composers or works. Going back to his time in Philly, he doesn’t really have much enthusiasm for contemporary or early repertoire.
Surprising RE: early music, since Muti has in his repertoire works by Vivaldi, Scarlatti, Caldara, Pergolesi and Bach. He really has little patience for HIP, but is too diplomatic / cares too much about his image in order to publicly admit it.
His 7 CDs of Cherubini (born 1760) are a major contribution at the highest performance level.
It’s high time to get rid of the composer-in-residence: it does no good for either the output of the composer, or the repertoire of the CSO.
Quick, and no googling, name a single piece, or whistle a single tune from a work, written by a CSO composer-in-residence for the CSO.
QED.
Not very clever. If whistleness of a tune would be the condition for new pieces, the entire oeuvre of Shostakovich, Britten, Stravinsky, Szymanowsky and many other great composers would not qualify.
It was in the 19th century when people insisted to be able to whistle a tune as a benchmark for musical appreciation. We have outgrown that kind of thing.
Are you kidding? I fell in love with The Rite of Spring when I was sixteen, and used to whistle large sections of it all the time, being homeless on the streets of Toronto, and lacking an instrument.
Yes, the Sacre is quite whistlable. But it is not the reason why it is a great work.
Great choice. Her music is wonderful and I think this will be a real opportunity for her. Congrats to all!