Football managers and orchestral maestros: same job, unequal pay

Football managers and orchestral maestros: same job, unequal pay


norman lebrecht

December 11, 2015

In this week’s Spectator magazine, I chart some remarkable similarities between soccer managers and the music directors of major orchestras.

You don’t have to be a follower of Liverpool Football Club, or football at all, to spot the difference. Two months ago the Reds were running about headless as a newly-wrung chook; today they are putting the fear of perdition into the best teams in the land

Or take Leicester City. Last season they were locked in an epic, desperate small-town struggle for Premiership survival. Today, they are top of the League.

What changed? Both teams have same players as before, same strip, roughly the same formation. The only new face is the manager’s. Change the boss and – presto – the mood picks up, tempi get faster, goals are scored, confidence rises and everyone charges around with a smile on their chops.

Just how that transformation is effected is a mystery even to those who take credit for it. The closest comparison is what happens when a symphony orchestra gets a new music director. Boston, for example, nearly dead in its seats under Seiji Ozawa and James Levine, is suddenly cock of the walk with young Andris Nelsons.  The LSO, so used to Valery Gergiev’s absences that players learned to conduct just in case, have a new spring in their fingers since Simon Rattle was elected. La Scala’s orchestra plays in an altogether different Liga with Riccardo Chailly in command.

And then I start identifying the idential twins. You can read the full article here.


The Special Ones: separated at birth?


UPDATE: An alternative interpretation:

mourinho gatti


  • Justthemfacts says:

    Rattle has barely swung the baton and LSO is better? Pure gibberish and reduces the importance of conducting to mere association. You know better.

  • RW2013 says:

    Not even on SD is one spared from reading about the most tedious, overrated sport on earth.

  • Hans-Dieter Glaubke says:

    By Jove! Such utter dribble. Slow day at the desk, Mr. Lebrecht?