Lorin Maazel was my mentor: a violinist’s tale

Lorin Maazel was my mentor: a violinist’s tale


norman lebrecht

July 16, 2014

The rising American violinist Eric Silberger has asked us to share some of his close memories of the late maestro:

eric silberger



He once told me, “always remain humble, our friendship depends on it.”

In front of the music, he was extremely humble and always dedicated to achieving the highest standards possible.Even though he had conducted the same works hundreds of times (for instance, the overture of La Forza del Destino), he always revisited the scores before bringing the music to life once again.

Once when I went last year to a performance of Don Carlo he was conducting at the Met, I saw him backstage during the intermission. He went on to speak very candidly about the performance and the music. He related to me that once in a previous performance of the opera, he had taken a leap in the podium that resulted in such a clatter that everyone in the pit looked up in surprise. It was a spontaneous decision that helped to realign the orchestra with the singers on stage and one which he told me he had never used before. He conducted a truly grand and moving rendition of the opera which lasted for 5 hours in which he stood the entire time.

Castleton is where I saw him at his most relaxed. Yet that did not stop him from rehearsing with the orchestra and singers here for 9 hours a day as recently as last summer. He told me that the weeks at Castleton were his “vacation”. I can certainly say that his vacation was more productive than any other I have ever seen! The music and atmosphere at Castleton is what helped reenergize him every year.

Throughout my time with him, he was always very encouraging both personally and musically. He once told me always to “trust your intuition.” (One) morning I was running (literally) on the farm here to a rehearsal and was picked up by a car he was riding in. He immediately started discussing aspects of phrasing and contrast. One thing he was always adamant about was not having “mezzo mezzo” playing. Contrasts in dynamics, colors, and expression, when used with the sincerity he had so much of, really brought life to the notes on the page.

He loved challenges and loved challenging others to see what limits there were to one’s abilities. Last summer, he put me to the test and asked me to learn the Barber Concerto in one day to play in a rehearsal with him conducting. He had a one track mind where anything he asked for he believed could happen–and it did. It was not unusual to work with him on a Mahler Symphony and Puccini Opera on the same day and then to play chamber music at night. Under his direction, I also served as principal in the orchestra, and co-founded the Castleton Chamber Players with my colleague Daniel Lelchuk.

I will miss not only the music he brought to the world, but also his eternal optimism, belief, fearlessness, and most of all his sincerity. His life is a true example of what is possible when you live your life to the fullest. I hope to as much as possible take what I learned from him and pass on his legacy every time I pick up the violin, a score, or have a moment to reflect and just enjoy. Living life in such a way is truly a life well spent.

(C) Eric Silberger/www.slippedisc.com


  • thekingontheviolin says:

    I am a friend and colleague of Eric Silberger. We have spoken many times about music and in particular violin playing and its transfiguration during the twentieth century from a “great lost world” into something more brazen and even phoney.

    In each and every conversation we have had on Skype it is not long before he mentions the influence Lorin Maazel has had on his development. Maestro Maazel was “old school”. He was a passionate believer and warrior in maintaining the standards of the “old school” and he would not allow it to disappear amid the plethora of technically perfect mediocrity.

    I am middle aged and particularly impressed with Eric’s determination to develop his talent along this path. Two trends have emerged. The first is that we must accept that the “old school” has died out. We must grieve its loss and allow something new to emerge which will also be authentic. The second is to combat the mediocrity and sameness which plagues the musical world under the guise of progress due to technical perfection obfuscating the underlying musical intent.
    Eric is a very fine violinist. His technical abilities are stunning and his background interesting for those of us who are violinists as he is half chinese and half jewish. His priority largely due to the influence of his mentor, friend and supporter Lorin Maazel of blessed memory, remains with a steadfast determination to develop his musical depth rather than glide on his technical prowess.

    I very much look forward to his performance at the Royal Festival Hall next April of Mozart K. 219.

    I spoke to him the day after his sad news and heard many beautiful stories from him about his relationship with Lorin Maazel. Some of his feelings he has expressed here in this tribute.

    I add that I noted a sense of personal loss and grief combined with an inspiration to continue his life in the style of his mentor which led me to understand that Lorin Maazel, whom I never met, must have been a very fine and kind human being.