Aaron Rosand: ‘A competition is not fair when teachers face their own students’
September 18, 2014 by norman lebrecht
The veteran virtuoso and teacher has commented, in a letter to Slipped Disc, on the finals of the Indianapolis contest, an outcome which has provoked widespread discomfort. We reprint his comments with permission:
A competition can not be fair when teachers have their own students involved in it. Although they can not vote for their pupils , they can easily give lower marks to more worthy candidates.
This practice must be discontinued to achieve fair and unbiased results.
Currently many outstanding young violinists are from Asia : that five of the six finalists chosen are Korean speaks well for their innate abilities and basic training .
However, four of the six are now studying with teachers on the jury.
You can draw your own conclusion.
Next Article Previous Article